Journal Article

The Valley House Hotel South New Berlin, New York

August 21, 2026 | Chenango County Historical Society Journal | 14 min read

By: A. Gail Merian

Historic buildings often remind people of the past or bring forth memories for area residents.   The former Valley House Restaurant and Hotel in South New Berlin is no exception. There was one story that the establishment may even have previously served as a stagecoach stop before transitioning into a restaurant, bar, and hotel.[1]

In 1982, a historic preservation form was completed, detailing the property as a hotel built during the 1870s featuring clapboard siding. The assessment indicated that the building was in good condition and included access to a rear parking lot via a driveway.  It was considered a Gothic Revival rambling hotel with gables and had a second story open porch “…with turned molding decorations above an enclosed porch on the south façade”[2] and a second story wing over an open car port.  The report continued to say it retained its architectural and thematic integrity “despites its slightly tawdry commercial bar room.”[3]

According to Leona Bagg, the Valley House began as a two-story home owned by Dr. William H. Kinner and set back from the road. The doctor’s home appears on an 1875 map.

 

Figure # 1 1875 Map Copied by Edythe Hewitt from an Atlas of Chenango County. Courtesy of the South New Berlin Nathan Taylor Yorker’s Museum

After the death of Kinner, Dr. John T. Hand lived there.  Charles Hayward later purchased the property and moved the house closer to the road and made it into a hotel.[4] As shown below, the hotel has changed ownership numerous times over the years.

Records indicate it was referred to as the Valley House as early as 1898[5] when it was sold to William M. Storrs of Lisle, New York who took possession on March 1st, 1898.[6]  In 1900, he rented it to Lew Sheff of New Berlin.[7]  Elizabeth Sperring sold it to Lewis Sheff in 1911.[8]

Figure # 2 Valley House (in back of photo) 1909 Courtesy South New Berlin Free Library

In 1914, Mr. Lucas assumed ownership of the Valley House as its new proprietor.[9]

Then, in 1927, Albert Lucas sold the Valley House to Paul Zydor who took possession April 1.[10]  In 1938, it was reported in the South New Berlin Bee that Paul Zydor sold The Valley House to Jack (John H.) Lindsey.

Paul Zydor owned the Valley House during part of the Prohibition era (1920 to 1933) where the Valley House attracted some notoriety. In its July 23, 1927, issue, the South New Berlin Bee reported that four federal agents raided the Valley House. Officials seized what was described as the largest haul: 2,958 bottles of home brew, five gallons of malt, 15 gallons of cider, and a capping machine.[11] The following year on August 4, 1928, federal agents returned to the Valley House, still operated by Zydor and found nine half barrels of beer.[12]  Zydor at this time was given a summons to appear before the U.S. Commissioner.

Jack Lindsey sold the Valley House to Major and Mrs. Richard J Forsyth in 1944 and it was operated by Mrs. Forsyth, as the Major was in Springfield, Massachusetts, helping make material for war production.[13]  About the same time, they were advertising to find a new cook. The Major returned in 1945 after his release from the military to help with the business.[14]

Then in 1953, Josephine Forsyth sold the Valley House to James D Ross. In 1976, James Ross sold it to Paul & Mary Risedorph and in 1980, Paul Risedorph sold it to James & Myra Swady.[15]

One South New Berlin resident remembered the Valley House:

“I remember the valley house, we were young, we used to go there to eat. I asked my father and aunt and uncle, The owners were Dorothy and Jim Ross (when) the top part burned, but they continued to stay open…”.

Figure # 3 Evening Sun Norwich, New York Thursday June 26, 1980. Page 6.

Foreclosure proceedings involving James and Myra Swady took place on December 2, 1982, with the property scheduled for sale at public auction in January, 1983.[16]  It is interesting to note though when the building inventory form for historic preservation was filled out in February 1982, Marvin Itkin was listed as the owner.

The Evening Sun in 1986 reported The Valley House still operating as a rooming house.

In 1995, twenty South New Berlin residents signed a petition to clean up the property, owned now by Lois Parker, because the building had become a health and safety hazard, and submitted it to town officials.[17]

The County became the owner after the delinquent taxes and the property was later condemned in 1997[18] and eventually torn down.

Figure # 4 1998 Snow caved in a portion of the roof, leaving the end of the upper roof bulging and threatening collapse. Press & Sun Bulletin Saturday January 10, 1998. Page 3.

The Valley House was an integral part of the community.  Local newspapers often mentioned the Valley House in ads or names of guests that would stay there from out-of-town, as well as people who would come to celebrate anniversaries, etc.  There was even a winter “Stag Party” held here in December 1920.[19] The Valley House was also involved in supporting activities within the community. Such as supporting a street dance held by the American Legion.[20] Even the United States Senator Irving Ives attended a dinner there for the Citizens committee in 1951.[21]

According to the South New Berlin Bee, organizations that met at the Valley House included the South New Berlin Baseball team, the Community Civic Club, the Sun Victory Chain League, the Exchange Club, and the Motor Club Federation. The Valley House also supported local groups by helping raise money for the South New Berlin Library book fund[22] and donated a desk in 1942.[23] In addition to providing food and lodging, it contributed to community causes, including the 1942 war fund drive.[24]

Various lodgers, including the state crew that was working in 1948 on the Route 8 construction, stayed at the Valley House Hotel.[25] Mr. and Mrs. Gies of Long Island were guests in 1948. The Valley House Hotel also accommodated hunters during hunting season.[26]

Other events occurred around the Valley House. As in 1916, Mrs. Will Washburne experienced an unexpected mishap on her way to town. When she arrived at Amblerville, a falling pole scared her horses. The horses bolted, with one eventually reaching South New Berlin, attempting to go between the Valley House and Smeader’s Hardware, where it was stopped after falling on the stone sidewalk in front of Smeader’s hardware. [27]

There was also an unfortunate incident in 1934 where there was a robbery at the Parker store when Mr. Zydor, proprietor at that time of the Valley House, said he saw no strangers around the Parker store when he closed at one AM.[28]

As time went on, the clientele staying at the Valley House Hotel changed, with characters often being found in the Police Blotter. In 1954, a patron tried to cash a $25 fraudulent check.[29] Then in 1987, two residents were charged with third degree falsely reporting an accident and petty larceny.[30]  In 1988, a resident was arrested for selling liquor to minors in Morris.[31]

As with all businesses, maintenance and updating were an ongoing project.

In 1906, L.H. Sheff, the proprietor of Valley House, expanded the establishment by adding a livery service.[32]  In 1921, the roof was partially shingled[33] and in 1927, the Valley House the roof was re-shingled.[34]   Also a new roof was added to the barn in 1928[35] and the porch was replaced in 1936, [36] as well as having a new coat of paint.[37]

Maintenance was a concern, but businesses also faced risks from storms and fires.  In 1926, a snowstorm caused their barn’s roof to collapse[38] and during a wind storm a tree fell on the rear part of the building causing damage to the roof.[39] The Valley House also was in the news when the Smeader Block in South New Berlin burned in 1927 and the Valley House was in two feet of the fire though they managed to save the Valley House with a lot of work.[40]

When businesses change ownership, new owners often try to make improvements.  Major and Mrs. Richard J Forsyth, who purchased the Valley House Hotel in 1944, decided in 1946 to undertake major renovations by installing cement steps, cherry woodwork, a tile block floor, new furniture, new lights, an arch over the bar with elephants (not pink), as well as updating the upstairs and basement.[41]

The Valley House promoted its business in different ways. For example, in 1945 the South New Berlin Bee advertised the Valley House Hotel as a dining room, bar, and grill.[42]

In 1950, The Valley House was again painted, this time by James Shillabeer.[43]

The Valley House periodically sold some of its equipment. For example, in 1938, the Valley House offered a coal range and warming oven for sale, and in 1940, a Maytag electric washing machine was sold.

The Valley House was also used for other venues such as Jack Clearo operating a barber shop here,[44] and as a venue to collect taxes.[45] F.L. Deforest also bought calves at this location in 1914. There was even an advertisement for the sale of millinery apparel here.[46]

Over the years, numerous local individuals were employed at the Valley House, including Earl Brownson, Mrs. Greenly as cook,[47] Mr. Pollard, [48] Myrtle Nelson[49] and George France[50]

Figure # 5 Valley House Photo by Gail Merian courtesy NB Nathan Taylor Yorker’s Museum.
Figure #6 Valley House South New Berlin June 1985 Courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #7 Valley House South New Berlin June 1985 Courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #8 Valley House Bar June 1985 photo courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #9 Valley House door Jun 1985 photo courtesy South New Berlin Library.
Figure #10 Valley House Electrified ice box Jun 1985 photo courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #11 Valley House Registration desk Jun 1985 photo courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #12 Valley House Wood staircase Jun 1985 photo courtesy South New Berlin Free Library.
Figure #13 Valley House wood Trim circa 1870 photo by Gail Merian courtesy South New Berlin Nathan Taylor Yorker’s Museum.

The Valley house was an integral part of the local community for over 80 years. There was an effort to try to preserve the Valley House Hotel but unfortunately it could not be preserved as a historic site. Subsequent owners were unable to maintain the business as effectively as their predecessors, leading to unpaid taxes and eventual deterioration of the property.  Even so, its story underscores the importance of documenting and preserving local history for future generations.

I would like to thank Julie Kupris, Chenango County Historical Research Assistant, Kay Benjamin, Tricia Munson, Nancy Dibbel and Robin Avolio of the South New Berlin Free Library for their invaluable help in research for this article.


 

[1]Wright, Jim. “The Chenango Community South New Berlin at Odds with County Over Building.”  Press & Sun Bulletin. Binghamton, New York. Saturday January 10, 1998. Page 3.
[2] Nechwert, Judith. Building Structure Inventory Form Division for Historic Preservation, February 1982.
[3] Ibid.
[4] Bagg, Leona. Records and Recollections of Leona Bagg. South New Berlin Chenango County, New York. 1976.
[5] Wright, Jim. “South New Berlin at Odds with County. Over Building. Community” Press and Sun Bulletin. Binghamton, New York. Saturday January 10, 1998. Page 3.
[6] “News of Other Years.”  The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday January 26, 1918. Vol XXIII No 3. Page 1.
[7] “News of Other Years.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday March 6, 1920. Vol XXIV No 28. Page 2.
[8] “Public Notice.”  The Evening Sun. Norwich, New York. Tuesday December 7, 1982. Vol 92 No 238 Page 9.
[9] “Local Items of Interest.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday December 19, 1914. Vol XVIII No 50 Page 5.
[10] “Items of Local Interest.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday February 19, 1927. Vol XXXI No 9. Page 3.
[11] “Federal Agents Raid Nine Places.” South New Berlin Bee. Saturday July 23, 1927. Vol XXXI No 26 Page 5.
[12] “Resorts Raided.” South New Berlin Bee. Saturday August 4, 1928. Vol XXXII No 28 Page 1.
[13] “Buy S. New Berlin Hotel.” The Norwich Sun. Norwich, New York. Saturday August 5, 1944. Vol 54 No 121 Page 4.
[14] “Major Forsyth is Returning to Civilian Life at Own Request.” The Telegraph. Norwich, New York. Friday May 25, 1945. Vol116 No 21 Page 3.
[15] “Public Notice.” The Evening Sun. Public Notice.”  The Evening Sun. Norwich, New York. Tuesday December 7, 1982. Vol 92 No 238 Page 9.
[16] “Public Noice.” The Evening Sun. Norwich, New York. Tuesday, December 14th,1982 Vol 92 No 43 Page 10.
[17] Bergamo, Karen. “Residents Sing Petition to Clean Up South New Berlin Properties.”  The Evening Sun. Tuesday May 16, 1995. Page 1.
[18] Wright, Jim. “South New Berlin at Odds with County. Over Building. Community” Press and Sun Bulletin. Binghamton, New York. Saturday January 10, 1998. Page 3.
[19] “Winter Stag” at the Valley House.”  South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday December 25, 1925. Vol XXIV No 24 Page 2.
[20] “Advertisement.”   South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday October 1, 1948. Vol 51 No 39. Page 3.
[21] “Meetings” The South New Berlin Bee. Friday November 16, 1951. Gilbertsville, New York. Vol 54 No 46. Page 1.
[22] “Library Notes.” The South New Berlin Bee. February 25, 1932. Vol XXXVI No 6 Page 8.
[23] “Local Items of Interest.” South New Berlin Bee. Friday May 1, 1942. Vol XLVI No 14 Page 5.
[24] “Red Cross News.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday February 20, 1942. Vol XLVI No 4 Page 4.
[25] “Route No 8 Construction at S.N.B. Underway.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday April 9, 1948. Vol 51 No15. Page 3.
[26]  “S.N.B. Local News Items.”  The South New Berlin Bee. Friday November 18, 1949. Vol 52 No 46 Friday Page 1.
[27] “Local Items.” The South New Berlin Bee. Saturday December 9, 1916. Vol XX No 49 Page 5.
[28] “Burglars Steal 150 Suits from the Parker Store.”  The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday August 3, 1934. Vol XXXVIII No 28. Page 1.
[29] “Waterville Man Held Here: Faces Bad Check Charge.” The Norwich Sun. Norwich, New York. Friday July 23, 1954. Vol 654 No 110 Page 3.
[30] “Police Blotter.”  The Evening Sun. Norwich, New York. Wednesday December 9, 1987.Page 2.
[31] “Police Blotter.” The Evening Sun. Friday August 5, 1988. Page 2.
[32] Payne, A.J. “Interesting Items of Many Years Ago.”  The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York Friday April 23, 1948. Vol 51 No 17. Page 4.
[33] “Local Items of Interest.” The South New Berlin Bee. The South New Berlin, New York. Saturday June 21, 1921. Vol XXV No 22 Page 5.
[34] “Local Items of Interest.”  The South New Berlin Bee. The South New Berlin, New York. Saturday August 13, 1927. Vol XXXI No 28. Page.
[35] “Local Items of Interest.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday June 2, 1928. Vol XXXII No 19. Page 5.
[36] The South Nee Berlin Bee. The South New Berlin, New York. Thursday May 28, 1936. Vol XL no 19. Page 5
[37] “Items of Local Interest.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday February 19, 1927. Vol XXXI No 7. Page 3.
[38] “Local Items of Interest.” The South New Berlin. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday February 20, 1926. Vol XXX No 4. Page 9.
[39] “Windstorm Damage.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday May 27, 1949. Vol 52 No 21. Page 1.
[40] “Smeader Block Burns.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday February 19, 1927. Vol XXXL No 4 Page 1.
[41] “Valley House at South New Berlin Shows Decided Improvements.” The Chenango Telegraph. Norwich, New York.  Friday February 22, 1946. Vol 177 No 8. Page 1.
[42] “Advertisement.”  The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York Friday June 18, 1945. Vol 51 No 24. Page 2.
[43] “So. New Berlin Local News.” The South New Berlin Bee. GIlbertsville, New York. Friday May 26, 1950. Vol 53 No 19 Page 1.
[44] “Deaths Jack Clearo.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York, Friday January 29, 1954, Vol 57 No 5 Page 5.
[45]“Collector’s Notice.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday January 3, 1941. Vol XLIV No 49. Page 5.
[46] “Millinery Notice.” South New Berlin Bee. Saturday August 26, 1922. Vol XXVI No 30 Page 4.
[47] “Local Items of Interest.” The South New Berling Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday March 24, 1939. Vol XLIII No 8. Page 5.
[48] “S.N.B Additional Local Items.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday September 2, 1949. Vol 52 No 35. Page 2.
[49] “Holmesville.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Friday June 21, 1940. Vol XLIV No 21 Page 8.
[50] “From the Bee Files.” The South New Berlin Bee. South New Berlin, New York. Saturday May 22, 1920. Vol XXIV No 20. Page 6.

Open Wed - Fri, 10 AM - 4 PM

Make a Donation

Donation Form